This order does not decide whether the petitioner is an Indian citizen or a Bangladeshi national, and it does not quash the movement-restriction order of 5 March 2026. It decides only that repatriation or deportation cannot proceed until the authorities take steps to determine nationality after affording the petitioner an adequate opportunity.
- Case
- Shri Adbul Rahim v State of Karnataka
- Court
- High Court of Karnataka
- Decision
- Citation
- 2026:KHC:62981
- Bench
- C.M. Poonacha
- Judgment by
- C.M. Poonacha
- Case numbers
- W.P. No. 19120 of 2026 (GM-RES)
- Outcome
- Writ petition disposed of; the movement-restriction order requiring the petitioner to reside at the Utile Foundation is not quashed, but the authorities must decide nationality after affording an adequate opportunity, and no repatriation or deportation may take place until then.
Deportation stayed, restriction upheld
The High Court of Karnataka has stayed the deportation of a man who says he is an Indian citizen, holding that the authorities must first decide his nationality through a fair process — even though the order confining him to a Bengaluru facility was itself within the law.
Justice C.M. Poonacha disposed of Writ Petition No. 19120 of 2026 on 13 November 2026. The petitioner, Abdul Rahim — spelt 'Adbul' in the cause title — had challenged a movement-restriction order of 5 March 2026 by which the Foreigners Regional Registration Officer, Bengaluru, referred him to the Utile Foundation at Kothanur until his repatriation.
Picked up in a drive, then restricted
The petitioner says he was born on 14 April 1979 at New Seemapuri, Delhi, moved to Bengaluru in 2014, and runs a waste-management and scrap-trading business, AR Enterprises. He lives with his wife and their infant child, aged six months. On 5 March 2026, Parappana Agrahara police picked him up during a drive to identify illegal Bangladeshi immigrants and handed him to the FRRO. He repeatedly asserted that he was an Indian citizen by birth and offered to produce documents; the FRRO passed the impugned order the same day, identifying him in it as 'Md Rahim Howladar'. His nephew joined as second petitioner, representing him while he was at the Foundation.
The petitioner had earlier been convicted by a Sessions Court in 2012 under Section 14-A(b) of the Foreigners Act, 1946, and sentenced to four years' rigorous imprisonment. His appeal, Criminal Appeal No. 2509 of 2012, is pending before the Allahabad High Court, which admitted it and granted bail on 6 July 2012 without staying the conviction. He also argued double jeopardy under Article 20(2) of the Constitution. A habeas corpus petition, WP (HC) No. 40 of 2026, was disposed of on 17 April 2026 with liberty to challenge the restriction order, and an interim order of 6 July 2026 restrained deportation.
The documents in dispute
The dispute turns largely on documents. In support of his claim, the petitioner produced a birth certificate, a passport issued on 20 June 2018, a voter identity card issued on 5 December 2005, an Aadhaar card, a PAN card, a driving licence, Udyam and GST registration certificates, a BBMP identity card, and his father's death certificate. The voter identity card is the earliest of these.
The authorities said the birth certificate was not genuine: the hospital it names, Guru Gobind Singh Government Hospital, was established only in December 1995, and no birth record existed; nor was there any record of his father's death certificate with the Municipal Corporation of Delhi. Two birth certificates he produced in different proceedings differed only in registration numbers and dates, though their details were the same. The FRRO's case was that the primary documents had been fraudulently obtained or fabricated, and that the secondary documents, issued on their basis, carried no legal sanctity.
The Court did not accept that the birth-certificate dispute could decide the case on its own: the two certificates carried the same details and had only been applied for on different dates, and the other documents — including a passport, issued after verification — showed that the petitioner had lived in India for a considerable time while consistently asserting Indian citizenship.
BANTHRY ANALYSISThe new legal framework
The legal framework starts with Section 3(1)(a) of the Citizenship Act, 1955, under which a person born in India between 26 January 1950 and 1 July 1987 is a citizen by birth — the provision the petitioner relies on. The Foreigners Act, 2025, empowers the Central Government by Section 7 to restrict a foreigner's presence, including requiring him to reside at a particular place under Section 7(2)(f)(ii); paragraph 8 of the Immigration and Foreigners Order, 2025, gives the civil authority that power.
Two features mattered. First, unlike Section 8 of the 1946 Act, the 2025 Act contains no provision for determining nationality as such; Section 15 deals only with persons who entered on a valid passport or visa, and Section 16 places the onus of proving that a person is not a foreigner on that person. Second, paragraph 16 of the Foreigners Order, 2025, leaves whether a person is or is not a foreigner to be decided by a Foreigners Tribunal.
The Court also examined the Home Ministry's communication of 2 May 2025, laying down the protocol for deporting illegal Bangladeshi nationals and Rohingya: where a person claims Indian citizenship, details are sent to the state and district he claims to hail from, verification is to be completed within 30 days, and the person is kept in a holding centre meanwhile. The authorities began that process only after the writ petition was filed, and the communication makes no mention of the Foreigners Act, 2025 or the Foreigners Order, 2025.
Fair procedure before removal
The Court's reasoning rests on the proposition that Articles 14 and 21 protect every person in India, including foreigners, and that a person whose citizenship is disputed is not outside that protection. It relied on the Supreme Court's decision in Sabitri Dey — the process for determining foreigner status must be fair, lawful and reasoned, even though the burden of proof remains on the person — and on Hasan Ali Raihany and NHRC v State of Arunachal Pradesh.
It also relied on the Calcutta High Court's order in Amir Khan, directing deported persons to be brought back, and the Gujarat High Court's decision in Rasidaben, directing release until nationality was decided. A coordinate Bench decision in Christopher Charles Kamolins, where post-decisional representation was held to satisfy natural justice, was distinguished: that case concerned an Australian on an employment visa whose documents were found fraudulent.
On the facts, the Court found no material showing that the petitioner had been told, before 5 March 2026, that he was alleged to be a foreign national, or that his documents had been considered before a conclusion was reached. Apart from the 2010 criminal case, no other case had been registered against him, and nothing suggested a national-security apprehension. The Court also declined to decide the nationality question itself for the first time in the writ petition.
- High Court of Karnataka: Shri Adbul Rahim v State of Karnataka, W.P. No. 19120 of 2026 (GM-RES), NC: 2026:KHC:62981 (official judgment, eSCR)paras 22-24, 55-58, 62, 65-66, 79; PDF pp. 18-23, 49-61, 64-65, 71-72
Operative directions
The Court upheld the legal basis of the restriction: Section 7(2)(f)(ii) of the Foreigners Act, 2025, empowers an order requiring a person to reside at a particular place, so the direction that the petitioner remain at the Foundation was not without authority of law — and the order directs residence rather than detention. But the authorities were bound to give him an opportunity to establish his citizenship before concluding he was a Bangladeshi national, which had not been done.
The operative direction is that the authorities must take further steps on nationality, having regard to the FRRO's counter-affidavit, after affording the petitioner an adequate opportunity, as expeditiously as possible. Until then, the petitioner is not to be repatriated or deported.
BANTHRY ANALYSISFor law students
The judgment separates two questions students should keep apart. The first is whether the state may restrict a suspected foreign national's movement: here, yes, because the statute expressly permits a residence direction. The second is whether the state may remove him: that requires a prior, fair determination of nationality, and the burden of proof lying on the individual does not remove the state's duty to follow a fair, lawful and reasoned process.
READING PROMPTSQuestions for a closer reading
- Why did the Court hold that the movement-restriction order was within the law, yet still stay any deportation?
- What does paragraph 16 of the Foreigners Order, 2025 say about who decides whether a person is a foreigner?
- How did the Court treat the dispute over the petitioner's birth certificate and other identity documents?