The order decides only the appeal against the Single Judge's judgment. Title to the land does not pass until the conveyance is executed and registered, and the judgment does not decide any question beyond the validity of the cancellation.
- Case
- State of Mizoram and Others v. Excel Vincom Private Limited and Another
- Court
- High Court at Calcutta
- Decision
- Bench
- Arijit Banerjee; Apurba Sinha Ray
- Case numbers
- FMA 772 of 2024
- Outcome
- Appeal dismissed; the Single Judge's judgment setting aside the cancellation and directing execution of the sale deed stands, with eight weeks from 13 November 2026 for compliance. No order as to costs.
Appeal dismissed; sale deed to be executed
The High Court at Calcutta has dismissed the State of Mizoram's appeal against a Single Judge's order setting aside the cancellation of a concluded sale of Mizoram House land in Kolkata, holding that the cancellation was unfair, unjust and arbitrary and violated Article 14 of the Constitution. A Division Bench of Justices Arijit Banerjee and Apurba Sinha Ray said the State had not demonstrated any public interest, far less an overwhelming one, that could justify undoing the sale, and described the decision as 'a clear case of regime revenge'.
FMA 772 of 2024 was decided on 13 November 2026. The court left the Single Judge's directions intact and gave the State eight weeks from the judgment to carry them out. There was no order as to costs.
A concluded sale, then a cancellation
The land is at 24, Ashutosh Chowdhury Avenue, Ballygunge, Kolkata, where the Mizoram Government's guest house, Mizoram House, stood. The old building was demolished in 2020 and a new construction plan was sanctioned in 2022. On 26 May 2023 the General Administration Department floated an e-tender-cum-e-auction for the land; Excel Vincom Private Limited was the highest bidder.
The company paid the entire consideration of Rs 38,29,91,994, after deducting tax at source, and an unregistered agreement for sale was executed on 6 October 2023. By 31 October 2023 it had paid Rs 18,98,82,000 by RTGS; the second instalment of Rs 19,18,00,000 followed with penal interest of Rs 35,86,660 at 1 per cent a month for 57 days. Only the execution and registration of the conveyance remained.
Elections were held in Mizoram in October 2023 and a new government took charge on 8 December 2023. Representations followed from the Kolkata Mizo Students (22 December 2023) and the Calcutta Mizo Welfare Association (27 December 2023), saying the property had historical significance and had served as a refuge for Mizo students and professionals in Kolkata. On 4 January 2024 the new government cancelled the entire e-tender process under Clause 3.1.11 of the bid document, read with Clauses 5.5 and 6.2, and refunded the entire money paid, including the earnest money.
Excel Vincom challenged the cancellation in WPA 1344 of 2024. Justice Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya allowed the petition on 2 April 2024, set the cancellation aside and directed the State to execute a sale deed. The State appealed.
Was the State entitled to cancel at the last step?
The question before the Division Bench was whether the State was justified in cancelling the entire tender process at a stage when only the formal execution of the conveyance remained. The State said the cancellation was not prompted by the change of government. It argued that the earlier government had not followed Rule 309 of the General Financial Rules, 2017, had not obtained the Council of Ministers' in-principle approval, and that the cancellation served a larger public interest.
It also argued that Clause 3.1.11 reserved an absolute right to cancel at any stage before the sale deed was signed, that an agreement for sale created no proprietary interest because title passes only on a registered conveyance, and that the writ petition was in substance a specific-performance claim belonging in a civil court. The company replied that no irregularity in the decision to sell had been shown, that official acts are presumed to have been regularly performed, and that the cancellation was plainly prompted by the change of government.
BANTHRY ANALYSISArticle 14 reaches into government contracts
The court began from the position that Article 14 applies to the State even in contractual matters. Relying on Shrilekha Vidyarthi v Union of India, it held that the guarantee against arbitrariness is not excluded merely because the dispute arises from a contract, though the scope of judicial review in such disputes may be narrower. A writ court may therefore examine whether a State's cancellation of a concluded tender is arbitrary, and an arbitration clause in the agreement does not oust Article 226 in every case.
On promissory estoppel, the court held that an Article 12 authority cannot back out of a solemn promise once the other side has acted on it, following Gujarat State Financial Corporation v Lotus Hotels and CIDCO v Shishir Realty. Where the Government says public interest requires it not to perform, it must satisfy the court how that interest overrides the contract and place material before the court; merely stating that public interest so requires is not enough.
No public interest was shown
The court rejected the State's reliance on Rule 309 of the General Financial Rules, holding that whether the Government followed its own financial rules is an internal matter and that a third party dealing with the Government is entitled to proceed on the basis that official acts were regularly performed. It also held that the absence of title until a registered conveyance did not entitle the State to go back on its promise: resiling from a duly executed agreement would breach it and entitle the purchaser to specific performance, and commercial dealings would otherwise become completely uncertain.
A reserved right to cancel, the court held, cannot be exercised arbitrarily, unfairly or unreasonably against a citizen. Execution of the sale deed had been deferred only because State elections were approaching; once they changed the ruling party, the government performed, in the court's words, 'a complete volta face' and cancelled the tender, citing greater public interest.
That public interest was never demonstrated. The court examined the two representations relied on by the State and held that neither showed any overwhelming public interest justifying cancellation of a tender process on the verge of completion. It distinguished the State's authorities, including MRF Ltd v Manohar Parrikar, Dresser Rand v Bindal Agro and Renaissance Distilleries, and agreed with the Single Judge that a discernible vested right had been created in the company. The new dispensation, the court concluded, had cancelled the process unilaterally, without even entering into a dialogue with the company.
Appeal dismissed; eight weeks to comply
The appeal stands dismissed. The court found no reason to interfere with the Single Judge's judgment, made no order as to costs, and extended by eight weeks from the judgment the time for the State to carry out the Single Judge's order — to execute the sale deed for the land at 24, Ashutosh Chowdhury Avenue, in terms of the agreement for sale.
The order decides only the appeal. Title does not pass until the conveyance is executed and registered.
BANTHRY ANALYSISFor law students
Three points matter. First, a change of government does not by itself undo the previous government's contracts: the State is an entity in perpetuity, and a new dispensation must show a real, overwhelming public interest, with material, before it can cancel a concluded transaction. Second, Article 14 travels into contracts: a tender clause reserving a right to cancel is read subject to fairness, not as a licence for arbitrary action. Third, promissory estoppel binds the State once the other side has paid in full and the parties have signed an agreement; the court treated the estoppel as having matured into contractual rights.
Notice also what the court did not decide. It did not hold that every tender cancellation is unlawful, and it did not decide title. Its holding turns on timing and proof: when the State acted, the transaction was complete in everything but the conveyance, and the State produced no material showing that public interest had outgrown the contract.
READING PROMPTSQuestions for a closer reading
- Why did the Division Bench hold that the State had failed to show the public interest needed to cancel the sale?
- How did the court deal with the State's reliance on Clause 3.1.11 of the bid document?
- What is the difference, on the court's reasoning, between the 'regime revenge' observation in CIDCO v Shishir Realty and the Division Bench's own finding at paragraph 63?