This order decides only the appeal against the trial court's conviction and sentence. It does not re-try the evidence, and it makes no finding on any question beyond whether the conviction and sentence should stand. The court records the victim's age from her birth certificate; the exact age figures stated by different witnesses varied, and the article states the age as it follows from the birth certificate.
- Case
- Sri Damba Rabidas v The State of Assam and Another
- Court
- Gauhati High Court
- Decision
- Citation
- 2026:GAU-AS:16601-DB
- Bench
- Michael Zothankhuma; Sanjeev Kumar Sharma
- Judgment by
- Sanjeev Kumar Sharma
- Case numbers
- Crl.A./102/2026
- Outcome
- Criminal appeal dismissed; conviction under Section 4(2) of the POCSO Act and the sentence of twenty years' rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs 10,000 affirmed.
Appeal dismissed, sentence affirmed
A Division Bench of the Gauhati High Court has dismissed an appeal against a 20-year prison sentence imposed for sexually assaulting a 13-year-old girl, holding that a victim cannot be disbelieved merely because she did not fight back, raise an alarm, or tell her neighbours at once.
Justices Michael Zothankhuma and Sanjeev Kumar Sharma affirmed the conviction and sentence imposed by the Special Judge at Golaghat on 25 June 2025: twenty years' rigorous imprisonment under Section 4(2) of the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012, and a fine of Rs 10,000, with one month's simple imprisonment in default of payment. The judgment records 12 November 2026 as the date of pronouncement; the eSCR listing shows 11 November 2026 as the decision date.
The case and the trial
The case began when the informant reported the matter at the Dhekial police out-post under Golaghat police station on the evening of 26 June 2022; the written ejahar was lodged at Golaghat police station the next morning. The informant, the girl's father, alleged that the accused, Damba Rabidas, had entered the house at about 11.30 am while he and his wife were away and sexually assaulted his daughter, who was then 13. Golaghat police station registered the case under Section 376 of the Indian Penal Code read with Section 6 of the POCSO Act, and the trial court framed charges under Sections 4 and 8 of the POCSO Act.
The prosecution examined twelve witnesses, including the medical officer and the investigating officer, and exhibited fifteen documents. The victim, referred to in the judgment as 'Miss X', gave evidence that the accused had gagged her, taken her to the kitchen and assaulted her while her younger sister was in the house. Her parents returned at about 4 pm, and the family then went to the police station. The accused denied the allegations entirely.
The medical officer who examined the victim on 27 June 2022 recorded injuries and a ruptured hymen, and said on clinical examination that she was definitely below 18. The forensic report on the seized garment was negative for semen. The accused examined two witnesses in his defence and said the case had been falsely lodged because of a dispute over a tea garden he had taken on lease from the victim's father.
The appellant's arguments
Before the High Court, the appellant argued that the victim and her younger sister gave contradictory accounts — about whether the victim had been sweeping or reading, when the accused left the house, and when the parents returned — and that the two accounts were mutually destructive. He also argued that the victim had not raised a hue and cry, had not told her neighbours, and had not tried to kick, bite or push the accused, though she said she had wanted to escape.
He further argued that the victim's age had not been properly proved, that her younger sister had admitted being tutored by her father, and that the case was a false one lodged to get the leased tea garden back before the lease expired.
BANTHRY ANALYSISNo rule of resistance
The Court rejected the argument that a victim's evidence must be discarded when she does not resist. 'Different people have different reactions to the same situation,' the Bench observed, 'and there cannot be any hard-and-fast rule that in every case of rape there must be active resistance on the part of the victim by way of biting, kicking, etc.' The victim's tender age was a relevant consideration, and the fact that she did not raise a hue and cry or inform her neighbours — which the Court attributed to possible shame and embarrassment — was no reason to discard her testimony.
The Court also held that the trial court had discarded the younger sister's evidence as tutored, so the contradictions between the two sisters did not require consideration: a witness held unreliable for being tutored cannot really be regarded as an eyewitness in the real sense of the term, and differences between her account and the victim's could not be used to reject the victim's evidence. On age, the Court relied on the birth register produced by the court witness, which recorded the victim's date of birth as 28 August 2008 and registration on 7 September 2008; the defence had not disputed that date in cross-examination.
Why the conviction stood
The Court found no material omissions or contradictions in the victim's evidence when compared with her statement to the investigating officer and her statement before the Magistrate, and held there was no sound reason to disregard it. The tea garden leased to the appellant lay adjacent to the house, and the defence evidence itself showed that the appellant tended that garden and was not at home that day — facts the Court said lent further credence to the victim's account.
The plea of false implication also failed. The defence witness who spoke of an altercation over the garden had said the informant threatened that he would 'see' the appellant, but none of that account had been put to the informant in cross-examination beyond a general suggestion of a false case, and the Court described the version as a made-up story. The medical evidence of injury supported the victim's account and, in the Court's view, negated the plea of false implication.
Operative outcome
The Bench concluded that it found no infirmity in the impugned judgment and sentence, which accordingly stood affirmed, and the appeal stood dismissed. The trial court record was directed to be sent back.
BANTHRY ANALYSISFor law students
The judgment is a study in how appellate courts assess a child witness. Minor inconsistencies between witnesses do not automatically destroy a prosecution case: the court asks whether the core account is consistent across the victim's statements, whether the contradictions come from a witness already found unreliable, and whether independent material — here, the birth register and the medical evidence — supports the account.
It also states the position plainly for students of evidence: the absence of physical resistance is not a legal requirement for believing a victim of sexual assault, and a court will not treat silence or delayed reporting as a reason, on its own, to disbelieve the victim.
READING PROMPTSQuestions for a closer reading
- Why did the High Court hold that the victim's failure to resist, or to raise a hue and cry, was no reason to discard her testimony?
- How did the Court deal with the contradictions between the victim's account and her younger sister's account?
- What evidence did the Court rely on to hold that the victim was a minor at the time of the incident?