This order decides only whether the trial court's decree under Order XXXVII of the Code of Civil Procedure was rightly passed for non-compliance with the leave-to-defend condition. It does not decide whether the electrical works were executed to the value claimed, whether the amount claimed was in fact due, or the merits of any defence the administration might have raised had it been allowed to defend. It also does not decide anything about the execution of the works without public tenders, which the judgment records only as a stated fact.
- Case
- Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir and Others v Shabir Ahmad Dar and Others
- Court
- High Court of Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh
- Decision
- Bench
- Moksha Khajuria Kazmi
- Judgment by
- Moksha Khajuria Kazmi
- Case numbers
- RFA No. 31 of 2024
- Outcome
- Civil first appeal dismissed; the trial court's Order XXXVII decree for Rs 57.23 lakh with interest and costs stands. The balance deposit of Rs 18.81 lakh, made on 25 July 2025 after the decree of 12 August 2023, did not revive the right to defend.
Appeal dismissed: the decree stands
The High Court of Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh has dismissed the Union Territory's appeal against a decree for Rs 57.23 lakh in favour of contractors who executed electrical works at the MLA Hostel in Srinagar, holding that the trial court committed no illegality in decreeing the summary suit.
Ms Justice Moksha Khajuria Kazmi, deciding RFA No. 31 of 2024 on 13 November 2026, held that the administration had indisputably failed to comply with the condition imposed when leave to defend was granted, and that depositing the balance amount nearly two years after the decree could not be treated as compliance retrospectively so as to revive the right to defend.
Electrical works at the MLA Hostel, executed without tenders
The respondents, contractors led by Shabir Ahmad Dar, claimed to have executed electrical works at the MLA Hostel in Srinagar during 2019–2020. The judgment records that the works were to the tune of Rs 37.82 lakh, that the funds were contributed by the Legislative Assembly Secretariat and released to the Directorate of Estates for the Executive Engineer, and that no public tenders were invited for the execution of the works.
In their application for leave to defend, the appellants contended that the works involved a total expenditure of Rs 57.32 lakh and had been executed at the verbal instructions of defendant No. 3. The respondents had sued under Order XXXVII of the Code of Civil Procedure, the summary procedure for suits based on written contracts and debts, and the trial court decreed the suit for Rs 57.23 lakh with interest and costs.
Conditional leave, a part deposit, and a decree
The Estates Department applied for leave to defend the suit. On 21 December 2022 the trial court allowed the application, subject to the appellants depositing Rs 37.82 lakh and filing a written statement within 30 days. The administration challenged that order by a petition under Article 227, CM(M) No. 89 of 2023, which was dismissed on 11 May 2023.
Only Rs 19.01 lakh was then available in the Sadder Treasury and was deposited on 26 March 2023 by cheque. The balance of Rs 18.81 lakh was deposited only on 25 July 2025. In the meantime, the trial court, finding that the pre-condition for leave to defend had not been fulfilled, decreed the suit on 12 August 2023 for Rs 57.23 lakh with interest under Order XXXVII, observing that it had no option but to draw a presumption that the defendants had failed to fulfil the pre-condition set for leave to defend.
The administration's case, and the contractors' answer
Before the High Court, the administration's principal ground was that a substantial portion of the amount directed to be deposited had already been deposited, but the trial court had not taken that fact into account while decreeing the suit for the entire amount. It also contended that the trial court had failed to consider the peculiar circumstances that occasioned the delay in depositing the remainder.
Its counsel argued that the entire Rs 37.82 lakh now stood deposited, of which Rs 19.01 lakh had already been released to the respondents, and that the trial court ought to have permitted the appellants to file their written statement and afforded them an opportunity to substantiate their defence. Counsel for the respondents answered that the appellants had themselves admitted in their leave application that the works, to the extent of Rs 37.82 lakh, had been executed, and that having failed to comply with the condition imposed on 21 December 2022, the suit was rightly decreed on 12 August 2023.
A late deposit cannot revive the right to defend
The Court accepted the respondents' position. It held that the appellants had indisputably failed to comply with the condition imposed by the trial court within the stipulated period, and that the deposit of the balance of Rs 18.81 lakh on 25 July 2025, much after the judgment and decree of 12 August 2023, could not be construed as compliance with the direction retrospectively so as to revive the right to defend the suit.
The Court added that the appellants had failed to place on record any cogent explanation justifying their failure to deposit the balance amount within the time granted. In those circumstances, it held, the trial court could not be said to have committed any illegality in decreeing the suit on account of non-fulfilment of the condition imposed while granting leave to defend. Finding no perversity or illegality in the order under challenge, it dismissed the appeal as devoid of merit.
BANTHRY ANALYSISFor law students: conditional leave under Order XXXVII
Order XXXVII provides a summary procedure in which the defendant has no automatic right to defend: the court must first grant leave, and it may grant leave unconditionally, or subject to conditions such as depositing the amount claimed or furnishing security. The condition is the price of the right to defend.
This judgment turns on what happens when that price is not paid in time. The trial court had made the right to defend conditional on a deposit within 30 days; the deposit came in two parts, the second nearly two years after the decree. The High Court's answer is that compliance after the decree is not compliance at all for the purpose of reviving the right to defend — a defendant cannot lose the suit for non-compliance and then cure the default retrospectively.
Note also the standard of review. The High Court did not re-decide the suit; it asked whether the trial court had committed any illegality or perversity in decreeing it. Because the non-compliance was admitted, there was nothing to interfere with — which is why the merits of the underlying claim were never reached.
READING PROMPTSQuestions for a closer reading
- What condition did the trial court impose when it granted leave to defend on 21 December 2022, and what happened when the condition was not met in time?
- Why did the High Court hold that depositing the balance of Rs 18.81 lakh on 25 July 2025 could not revive the right to defend?
- What does this judgment not decide about the underlying dispute over the electrical works?