This order suspends the sentences pending appeal; it does not set aside the convictions, does not acquit the appellants, and expresses no view on the merits of the appeals, which remain to be heard.
- Case
- Bipinchand Kanaiyalal Joshi @ Lala Doctor v. State of Gujarat
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Decision
- Bench
- M. M. Sundresh; Prasanna B. Varale
- Case numbers
- SLP (Crl) No. 5265–5266 of 2026
- Outcome
- Record of proceedings dated 28 October 2026: leave granted, sentences suspended, bail granted on terms to be imposed by the Trial Court, appeals listed for hearing in due course.
Sentences suspended; bail granted; appeals to be heard
On 28 October 2026, the Supreme Court suspended the life sentences of two men convicted in the case arising from the 2002 gangrape and murder of Bilkis Bano, and granted them bail on terms and conditions to be imposed by the Trial Court. The order was reported on 16 November 2026.
A Bench of Justices M. M. Sundresh and Prasanna B. Varale granted leave in the appeals, noting that the appellants have been in custody for more than 17 years and that one of them is severely handicapped, and that issues remain to be decided in the appeals, both on fact and on law. The appeals will be heard in due course.
Life sentences confirmed by the High Court in 2017
The appellants were convicted for offences punishable under Sections 143, 147 and 302 read with Section 149, and Sections 376(2)(e) and 376(2)(g) of the Indian Penal Code, 1860, and sentenced to rigorous imprisonment for life with fine, in Sessions Case No. 634 of 2004 arising from FIR No. 59 of 2002 registered at Police Station Godhra Town, District Panchmahal, Gujarat.
The High Court of Bombay, by its final judgment and order dated 4 May 2017 in Criminal Appeals Nos. 1022 and 1023 of 2009, confirmed the conviction and sentence of the Trial Court. The appellants then approached the Supreme Court in Special Leave Petitions (Criminal) Nos. 5265–5266 of 2026.
Seventeen years in custody; the State opposes
For the appellants, senior counsel submitted that they have been under incarceration for more than 17 years, that one of the appellants was not named in the FIR and was implicated after a substantial period of nearly three years from the occurrence, and that one of the appellants is severely handicapped.
The Additional Solicitor General, appearing for the respondents, vehemently opposed the contentions, on the premise that both the courts below had taken into consideration the relevant material on record, especially when the offence committed is so serious.
The reason: long custody, handicap, arguable issues
The Court recorded that the appellants have been under incarceration for more than 17 years and that one of them has a severe handicap, and observed that there are issues to be decided in the appeal, both on fact and law.
The reasoning is deliberately narrow. The Court made no finding on the evidence, did not disturb the findings of the courts below, and did not suggest any view on whether the convictions are right or wrong. It treated the length of custody already undergone and the handicap of one appellant, together with the existence of arguable issues, as sufficient reason to suspend the operation of the sentences while the appeals remain pending. The State's opposition — that both courts below had considered the relevant material and that the offence was serious — was recorded but did not prevent suspension where the appellants had already spent more than 17 years in custody.
Bail on the Trial Court's terms; conviction intact
In view of the above, the Court suspended the sentences and granted bail to the appellants on such terms and conditions as may be imposed by the Trial Court. The appeals were directed to be listed for hearing in due course.
The order changes the appellants' custody status, not their convictions. They remain convicted persons whose appeals are pending; their liberty now depends on the bail terms the Trial Court imposes and on the eventual hearing of the appeals.
BANTHRY ANALYSISFor law students
This order is a compact study in the difference between suspension of sentence and acquittal. Suspension pauses the execution of the sentence while the appeal is pending; it does not erase the conviction, and it does not decide the appeal. Students should notice what the Court did not do: it recorded no finding on the evidence, it did not re-weigh the concurrent findings of the Trial Court and the High Court, and it expressly reserved the issues of fact and law for the hearing.
The factors that moved the Court are also worth noting. Length of incarceration already undergone is a recognised consideration in suspension of sentence, and here it was more than 17 years; the severe handicap of one appellant was a second, personal factor; and the submission that one appellant was not named in the FIR and was implicated nearly three years after the occurrence supplied an arguable issue for the appeal. None of these amounts to a finding in the appellants' favour — together, they were enough to keep the appellants on bail while the appeals are decided.
READING PROMPTSQuestions for a closer reading
- What two facts did the Court rely on in suspending the sentences, and what did it expressly leave undecided?
- How is suspension of sentence pending appeal different from an acquittal?
- Who fixes the terms and conditions of the bail granted, and what happens to the appeals now?