Permission to fell is not yet operative: no tree may be felled until prior Central Government approval for diversion of 0.1272 hectares of protected forest land is obtained and the compensatory-afforestation conditions are complied with.
- Case
- In Re: Vision Document for the Taj Trapezium Zone
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Decision
- Bench
- Chief Justice of India; Joymalya Bagchi; V. Mohana
- Case numbers
- Suo Motu Writ Petition (Civil) No. 7 of 2026
- Outcome
- Order allowing applications for felling 49 trees subject to Central Empowered Committee conditions and prior Central Government approval; matter listed on 19 November 2026.
49 trees, not 51 — and no felling until clearance and planting
On 6 November 2026, the Supreme Court allowed applications by the Bharatpur Municipal Corporation seeking permission to fell trees for a flood-control drain project in the Taj Trapezium Zone, permitting the felling of 49 trees instead of the 51 sought. The order was uploaded to the Court's website on 16 November 2026.
The permission is conditional, not immediate. No tree may be felled until the Corporation obtains the prior approval of the Central Government for diversion of 0.1272 hectares of protected forest land, and complies with the conditions recommended by the Central Empowered Committee (CEC), including planting 510 saplings as compensatory afforestation.
A flood-drain project through protected forest land
The applications concerned the project titled 'Construction/Rehabilitation of City Flood Control Drain (CFCD), Ranjeet Nagar Flood Control Drain (RNFCD), and Storm Water Drains in Deficient Areas with Allied Works on Lumpsum Turnkey Basis in Bharatpur town, District Bharatpur, Rajasthan', falling within the Taj Trapezium Zone.
The project involves a stretch of the proposed drain measuring about 5.0 metres by 3.5 metres, between Gandhi Nagar, Sector-13 and Heeradas Kunda drains, passing through the Central Nursery Area in Bharatpur, which is protected forest land. A joint inspection conducted on 3 February 2025 recorded that no work had commenced without sanction, and the Deputy Conservator of Forests, Bharatpur, recommended the project subject to the Court's permission for felling. The proposal for prior approval of the Central Government for diversion of the forest land had been submitted on the PARIVESH portal, and the Corporation had undertaken to plant 510 saplings — ten times the number of trees proposed to be felled — towards compensatory afforestation.
The CEC: two trees can be saved; the amicus agrees
When the Court issued notice on 23 February 2026, it directed that a copy of the application be supplied to the CEC for its recommendations. The CEC filed Report No. 14 of 2026, dated 17 July 2026, recommending that 49 trees be felled instead of 51 — serial numbers 19 and 41 could be saved — and retaining the proposal to plant 510 saplings, as against the requirement of 490 trees, since the identified land could accommodate them.
The amicus curiae, Senior Advocate Liz Mathew, reproduced the CEC's recommendations in her note and submitted that permission to fell 49 trees may be granted as recommended, subject to the conditions in paragraph 16 of the CEC report. She added that it should be expressly incorporated, per conditions (h) and (i) of that paragraph, that diversion of the 0.1272 hectares of protected forest land would require prior approval of the Central Government under Section 2(1)(ii) of the Van (Sanrakshan Evam Samvardhan) Adhiniyam, 1980. The Court agreed with the conditions recommended in paragraphs 6 and 7 of the amicus note.
Twelve conditions: planting, fencing, funds first, penalty for extras
The Court allowed the applications subject to the twelve conditions in paragraph 16 of the CEC report. The Divisional Forest Officer, Bharatpur, must undertake compensatory afforestation by planting 510 saplings of indigenous species on already identified non-forest land, at the applicant's cost, and 0.880 hectares of that land must be notified as Protected Forest by the Government of Rajasthan under Section 29 of the Indian Forest Act, 1927.
The plantation site must be protected by a six-feet-high chain-link fence fixed on a two-feet-high concrete or brick footwall, with provision for watering during summer and maintenance for ten years, the cost included in the project estimate. The funds for the afforestation, fencing and maintenance, as estimated by the State Forest Department, must be deposited by the applicant with the Divisional Forest Officer before any felling permission is issued. If any tree other than those permitted is felled or damaged, a penalty of ₹1 lakh per tree is recoverable. Dust-mitigation measures must be implemented during construction at the project proponent's cost, the Chairman of the TTZ Authority must ensure strict compliance, and a compliance report must be submitted to the CEC through its online portal.
Clearance first, planting verified, then felling
Two conditions are decisive. Under conditions (h) and (i), the applicant must obtain the prior approval of the Central Government under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 before diverting the forest land, and no felling is permitted by the Forest Department unless and until that approval is obtained and the compensatory-afforestation conditions are complied with. The Court added that the applicant must obtain prior approval for diversion of the 0.1272 hectares, that the CEC must submit a further report on the compensatory afforestation of 510 saplings at the identified land, and that only thereafter may the trees be felled. The applicant must also pay the cost of compensatory afforestation as per the schedule approved by the CEC. The matter is listed on 19 November 2026.
The order therefore does not authorise immediate felling: it authorises felling after clearance, payment and verified planting.
BANTHRY ANALYSISFor law students
This order shows the Court's standard operating method in Taj Trapezium Zone cases: nothing is decided on assertion alone. The Corporation's request went to the CEC, the CEC inspected and counted — 51 trees requested, 49 recommended, two saved by number — and the Court adopted the expert body's conditions wholesale, adding only the express incorporation of the statutory precondition.
Students should note the sequencing, which is the real holding. Compensatory afforestation is not a postscript: the funds must be deposited before any felling permission issues, the land must be notified as Protected Forest, and the CEC must report back before a single tree falls. The prior approval of the Central Government under the Forest (Conservation) Act is a separate, independent gate — the Court's permission does not substitute for it. That two-gate structure (court permission plus statutory approval) is what keeps a development permission from becoming a fait accompli.
READING PROMPTSQuestions for a closer reading
- Why did the Court permit 49 trees to be felled rather than the 51 sought, and which two trees were saved?
- What two preconditions must be satisfied before any felling may take place?
- What compensatory-afforestation obligations did the Court impose, and who must verify compliance?