The 329-tree permission for the Bharatpur road is conditional: felling may begin only after the Forest Department completes the compensatory afforestation, the CEC inspects it and files its report. The Firozabad request for 739 trees is undecided.
- Case
- In Re: Protection of Trees and Green Cover in the Taj Trapezium Zone
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Decision
- Bench
- Chief Justice of India; Joymalya Bagchi; V. Mohana
- Case numbers
- Suo Motu Writ Petition (Civil) No. 8 of 2026
- Outcome
- Omnibus order in the Taj Trapezium tree-protection proceedings: two felling permissions granted (one immediate, one conditional on verified compensatory afforestation); Firozabad request referred to the CEC; remaining applications listed on 19 November 2026.
Two permissions, one conditional; one request referred to the CEC
On 6 November 2026, the Supreme Court passed an omnibus order in the suo motu proceedings on protection of trees and green cover in the Taj Trapezium Zone, dealing with several pending applications for felling trees; it was uploaded to the Court's website on 16 November 2026.
The Court permitted the felling of 44 trees at the Mathura Military Station, where the Central Empowered Committee (CEC) had verified that 1,550 saplings were planted, alive, healthy and protected. It also dealt with a road-widening request in Bharatpur, recommending 329 trees for felling but making the permission conditional on the Forest Department first completing the compensatory afforestation and the CEC inspecting and reporting on it. A request to fell 739 trees for a road in Firozabad was referred to the CEC, and the remaining applications were listed on 19 November 2026.
Mathura military station: 60 trees sought, 44 recommended
The first applications were filed by the Administrative Commandant, Station Headquarters, Mathura Cantonment, for Headquarters, 99 Artillery Brigade and its allied units, seeking permission to fell 60 trees in the proposed construction area of Phase-I of the Key Location Plan at Mathura Military Station.
On 22 April 2025 the Court referred the matter to the CEC, directing the applicant to disclose the trees required for all three phases; the applicant then said plans for Phases II and III were yet to crystallise and sought independent consideration of Phase-I. The CEC submitted Report No. 6 of 2026, dated 20 February 2026, recommending felling of 44 trees instead of 60, subject to conditions in paragraph 17 of the report.
Verified planting first: 1,550 saplings alive and protected
The CEC's conditions required at least 550 compensatory saplings, maintained for five years, with felling permitted only after the plantation was carried out and verified by the Forest Department; and at least 1,000 further native saplings within its campus (300 ficus, 500 neem, arjun, dhak, ber and mango, 200 kachnar and amaltas), in consultation with the Divisional Forest Officer, Mathura, maintained for five years. The Chairman of the TTZ Authority was to ensure strict compliance, with a penalty of ₹1 lakh per tree for any additional felling or damage.
On 3 September 2026 the Court had disposed of one application after recording the applicant's statement that the conditions had been complied with, but directed the CEC to verify the compliance independently. The CEC's Report No. 33 of 2026, dated 30 October 2026, recorded inspections by the Social Forestry Division on 27 August 2026 and by the CEC on 23 September 2026, finding all 1,550 saplings present, alive, healthy and adequately protected. The Court accepted the recommendation, allowed the applications and accorded permission for felling 44 trees, directing that the CEC's compliance report be uploaded on the MIS module.
Bharatpur road: wider shoulders pushed the count from 236 to 329
The second set of applications was filed by the Rajasthan State Road Development and Construction Corporation Limited, seeking permission to fell trees for widening and strengthening of the Bharatpur–Bayana–Gangapur–Bhadoti road from KM 7/0 (Sewar) to KM 33/055 (Salabad). The CEC's Report No. 64 of 2025, dated 27 November 2025, had recommended felling of 236 trees (215 green and 21 dry), against the original request.
On 3 September 2026 the Court noted the Corporation's submission that at least 335 trees were required for widening the road from 7 to 10 metres, and directed it to comply with the compensatory-afforestation condition and file a compliance affidavit, with the CEC to reconsider the request. The CEC's Report No. 34 of 2026, dated 2 November 2026, observed that the 10-metre widening had already been accounted for, and that the additional requirement arose because the applicant had since modified the road design, increasing the paved shoulders from 50 cm to 100 cm on either side for safety, and sought 99 additional trees on that account. On inspection the CEC found 6 of those trees could be saved, and recommended felling of 329 trees (308 green and 21 dry).
329 trees, but only after planting is done and inspected
The CEC's conditions for the road included compensatory plantation of 4,180 indigenous trees by the Divisional Forest Officer, Bharatpur, at the applicant's cost on land identified in Village Katariyapur; notification of 4.5 hectares as Protected Forest within six months; fencing, watering and ten years' maintenance; deposit of the funds in an interest-bearing bank account before any felling permission; roadside planting of tall indigenous saplings with tree guards after the work; identification of the missing trees; a ₹1 lakh penalty per additional tree felled or damaged; and a compliance affidavit under paragraph 31 of the Court's order of 3 September 2026.
The amicus curiae, Senior Advocate Liz Mathew, noted that the compensatory afforestation had not yet been carried out — Report No. 64 of 2025 merely recorded the applicant's undertaking — and suggested the applicant first carry out the afforestation and file a compliance affidavit for the CEC to examine, including by site inspection. Counsel for the applicant informed the Court that ₹1,07,33,630 had already been deposited with the Forest Department and that the land for compensatory afforestation had been identified.
The Court accordingly directed the Forest Department, Government of Rajasthan, to immediately commence the compensatory afforestation and inform the CEC in writing on completion, after which the CEC is to inspect the site and report — and only once that report is filed is permission granted for felling the 329 trees. The needful is to be done within two months, the Forest Department must also report to the CEC on the missing green and dry trees, and the applications stand disposed of.
Firozabad referred to the CEC; the rest listed on 19 November
Three further items were dealt with. The Public Works Department, Firozabad, sought permission to fell 739 trees to four-lane the Tundla–Awagarh Road (State Highway No. 31), involving diversion of 8.7335 hectares of protected forest land; its forest-clearance proposal, recommended by the Divisional Director, Social Forestry Division, Firozabad, on 20 June 2026, is still pending. The Court directed the CEC to submit a self-explanatory report-cum-recommendation, including the status of approval under the Van (Sanrakshan Evam Samvardhan) Adhiniyam, 1980 and the width of the road, and posted the matter on 19 November 2026.
An application concerning air-pollution measures was de-tagged and directed to be listed with Suo Motu Writ Petition (Civil) No. 11 of 2026 on curbing air pollution in the National Capital Region. POWERGRID Ghiror Transmission Limited was permitted to move an application with its undertaking under the CEC's Reports Nos. 30 and 31 of 2026; its applications, those of the Railways and the Ministry of Defence, CEC Report No. 4 of 2026 and the UPSIDA applications were all listed on 19 November 2026, with copies to the amicus in advance.
BANTHRY ANALYSISFor law students
The two permissions illustrate a single principle applied two ways. At Mathura, the applicant planted first and the CEC verified — 1,550 saplings counted on site — so permission followed. On the Bharatpur road, the planting had not yet been done, so the Court reversed the sequence: plant, verify, and only then fell.
Students should also note how the Court handles scale. The road's tree count grew from 236 to 329 not because the road got longer but because the design changed — wider paved shoulders. The CEC counted again, saved six trees, and attached a heavier compensatory obligation (4,180 trees) plus roadside planting. A design change is a fresh fact: the permission is re-examined, not rubber-stamped.
READING PROMPTSQuestions for a closer reading
- Why was the Mathura military station permitted to fell 44 trees immediately, while the Bharatpur road permission was made conditional?
- What did the CEC's site inspections verify before the Court granted the Mathura permission?
- What remains undecided after this order, and when is the matter next listed?