This order decides only whether cognizance and process were lawfully taken in the defamation complaint. It does not decide whether the statements are defamatory in fact, whether any exception to defamation applies, or whether the accused is guilty. Those questions, and whether the complainant's reputation was in fact lowered, remain for trial.
- Case
- Sri Basanagouda Ramanagouda Patil Yatnal v Sri Shivananda S Patil
- Court
- High Court of Karnataka
- Decision
- Bench
- Anant Ramanath Hegde
- Judgment by
- Anant Ramanath Hegde
- Case numbers
- Crl.P. No. 12881 of 2026
- Outcome
- Criminal petition dismissed; the cognizance order of 24 January 2026 and the revisional order of 18 August 2026 stand, and the defamation proceedings in PCR No. 11492 of 2025 will proceed.
Petition dismissed
The High Court of Karnataka has refused to quash a defamation case against Basanagouda Patil Yatnal, a member of the Karnataka Legislative Assembly, holding that at the stage of taking cognizance a magistrate need not insist on a witness saying that the complainant's reputation fell in that witness's own estimation.
Justice Anant Ramanath Hegde dismissed Criminal Petition No. 12881 of 2026, upholding the order of 24 January 2026 by which the XLII Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Bengaluru, took cognizance of an offence under Section 356(2) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, in PCR No. 11492 of 2025, and the order of 18 August 2026 by which the Sessions Court affirmed it in revision.
The complaint
The complaint was filed on 18 July 2025 by Shivananda S Patil over statements allegedly made by the accused on 30 April 2025 on a channel named 'Gadinaada Kranti' and broadcast on YouTube. The complainant said in his sworn statement that his reputation had been lowered in the estimation of others because of the imputation. He cited three witnesses; two were examined, and both said the complainant's reputation had gone down in the estimation of others, while also saying the allegations were false.
The accused did not dispute having made the statements, which the complainant said had been widely circulated on social media. The judgment reproduces the remarks complained of in Kannada; they are not repeated here. The trial court, in a 17-page order, took cognizance under Section 223 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, and issued summons returnable by 12 December 2025.
The question
The question before the High Court was whether Explanation 4 to Section 356(1) of the BNS requires the complainant, at the stage of taking cognizance and issuing process, to examine a witness who would state that the complainant's reputation has been lowered in that person's own estimation — or whether it is enough that a witness other than the complainant, or other material, indicates that the imputation has lowered the reputation in the estimation of others.
The petitioner argued that unless the person in whose estimation the reputation was lowered made a statement to that effect, Explanation 4 was not satisfied and cognizance could not be taken. The complainant argued that the statements were per se defamatory, and that at the cognizance stage the magistrate need not insist on a third person's statement about his own estimation.
BANTHRY ANALYSISReading Explanation 4
Explanation 4 to Section 356(1) provides that no imputation harms a person's reputation unless it lowers the person's moral or intellectual character, character in respect of caste or calling, or credit, in the estimation of others. The Court held that a plain reading of the provision does not confine 'the estimation of others' to the witnesses examined before the court: the possible damage to reputation may be prima facie inferred from the circumstances of the publication and the contents of the imputation itself.
The Court also drew a careful distinction between two kinds of evidence. A witness who personally heard another person say the complainant's reputation had fallen is a direct witness to that statement being made, and the fact of the statement is admissible — though it may not conclusively prove the reputational harm. A witness who only heard about such an opinion second-hand is giving hearsay evidence.
Per se defamation at cognizance
Applying that approach, the Court held that where the imputation is per se defamatory — capable of lowering moral or intellectual character, or of projecting a person as of bad character or as having engaged in conduct generally considered disgraceful — the court may tentatively conclude that the reputation might have been lowered, for the purpose of taking cognizance. Where the imputation is not prima facie capable of doing so, a mere assertion may not suffice, and the magistrate may require further material or an independent witness who says the reputation fell in his own estimation.
The Court relied on the Supreme Court's decision in John Thomas v Dr K Jagadeesan, which held that a per se defamatory statement relieves the complainant of the burden of showing that publication lowered his reputation in the estimation of the right-thinking public. It declined to follow the Calcutta High Court's view in Aveek Sarkar that an independent witness's statement is invariably required, and distinguished the Madras High Court's decision in S Ranganathan, noting that two witnesses had in fact been examined here, so there was no procedural violation. The Supreme Court's decision in Jaideep Bose was also distinguished on its facts.
Operative outcome
On the statements themselves, the Court had no difficulty in taking a prima facie view that they cast serious aspersions on the complainant's integrity and character and were inherently capable of lowering his reputation. It held that the cognizance order could not be said to be erroneous, because at that stage the court need not consider whether the evidence is sufficient to convict.
Whether the public or any person believed the imputation, and whether the complainant's reputation was in fact lowered, are questions for trial, the Court said. The petition was dismissed, with the Court making clear that its observations were not an opinion on the merits of the complaint or the defence, and that all contentions on merits remain open before the trial court.
BANTHRY ANALYSISFor law students
The judgment separates two stages that students often confuse. At cognizance, the magistrate asks only whether a prima facie case is made out — and for a per se defamatory imputation, the words themselves can supply that answer. At trial, the complainant must prove the ingredients of defamation, including actual lowering of reputation, and the accused may raise the statutory exceptions.
It is also a useful illustration of how courts handle evidence about reputation: a witness can testify to having heard someone lower their opinion of the complainant, but that proves the statement was made, not necessarily that the reputation fell — and second-hand accounts of such opinions are hearsay.
READING PROMPTSQuestions for a closer reading
- What does Explanation 4 to Section 356(1) of the BNS require, and why did the Court hold it does not invariably require a witness to say the complainant's reputation fell in that witness's own estimation?
- When will a magistrate at the cognizance stage require further material or an independent witness, according to this judgment?
- Why did the Court decline to follow the Calcutta High Court's view in Aveek Sarkar?